Asbestos Industry Cover-Up
The history of concealed research, worker warnings and internal correspondence.
Overview
The asbestos industry cover-up is one of the most thoroughly documented cases of corporate concealment of a public health hazard and it’s a big part of why asbestos became the longest-running mass tort litigation in U.S. history. The core of it is this: the dangers of asbestos were known far earlier than the public was told and major manufacturers actively suppressed that knowledge for decades. Warnings go back a long way – even Roman writers noted sickness in workers who handled the material – but the modern paper trail begins in the 1920s and 30s. In 1924, the death of a British factory worker led a pathologist to coin the term “asbestosis” and by 1930 a major UK government report (Merewether and Price) documented lung disease in a large share of asbestos textile workers. The industry was aware of this research.
Scientific Suppression
Beyond suppressing publicity, the industry shaped the science. In the 1930s and 40s, research by Dr. Leroy Gardner at the Saranac Laboratory found tumors in asbestos-exposed lab animals, but industry sponsors influenced how – and whether – those cancer findings were published, with the concerning results softened or omitted. Companies also often withheld X-ray results from their own workers, meaning employees weren’t told their lungs were showing damage. The cover-up became harder to maintain in the 1960s when a South African study (Wagner and colleagues) firmly linked crocidolite asbestos to mesothelioma. Then, in 1964, Dr. Irving Selikoff of Mount Sinai published landmark research establishing the asbestos-disease connection in insulation workers, bringing it to wide public and medical attention. The industry pushed back on this research, but the tide had turned.
The Sumner Simpson Papers
The most damning evidence came from the internal correspondence uncovered during litigation decades later when plaintiffs’ attorneys obtained the internal documents in 1977, which came to be known as the Sumner Simpson papers. The Sumner Simpson papers were roughly 6,000 pages of correspondence from the 1930s involving the president of Raybestos-Manhattan and executives from other asbestos companies, including Johns-Manville (the largest asbestos company), showing a deliberate strategy to keep asbestosis out of trade publications, with the sentiment that the less publicity the topic received, the better for business. There’s also testimony recounting a Johns-Manville attorney (Vandiver Brown) reportedly acknowledging that the company would let workers stay on the job without warning them until they were disabled, because it was cheaper than the alternative.
Profits Over People
In a letter dated October 1, 1935, to Johns-Manville’s attorney Vandiver Brown, Sumner Simpson states that “the less said about asbestos, the better off we are.” In the same letter, Simpson notes that the trade journal, Asbestos, had “been very decent about not re-printing the English articles” – a reference to British research linking asbestos to lung disease. Brown reportedly replied in agreement that the topic should get minimal publicity. A 1939 letter from the publisher of Asbestos to Simpson acknowledged the arrangement plainly: “Always you have requested that for certain obvious reasons we publish nothing, and, naturally your wishes have been respected.”
A 1949 memo from Dr. Kenneth Smith, a Johns-Manville physician, shows concealment in the form of advising against telling seven mill workers about the chest X-rays he had reviewed showing early asbestosis. Smith’s reasoning, as later quoted in litigation, was that as long as a man is not disabled he should not be told of his condition so he can live and work in peace, and the company can benefit from his years of experience. In 1966, the director of purchasing for asbestos manufacturer Bendix Corp. wrote: “If you have enjoyed a good life while working with asbestos products, why not die from it?”
The most damning piece of testimony surfaced in 1985 during the deposition of former Unarco employee Charles Roemer, who described a meeting from the early 1940s where Johns-Manville executives mocked a competitor for warning its sick employees. Roemer testified that he asked whether the company would really let their employees work until they dropped dead, and the reply was: “Yes. We save a lot of money that way.”
Taken together, these documents let plaintiffs’ attorneys argue not merely negligence, but knowing concealment – which is what unlocked punitive damages, ultimately driving Johns-Manville into its 1982 bankruptcy and the trust system that followed. However, many companies that produced and/or sold asbestos-containing products have still never filed for bankruptcy and still defend mesothelioma cases in the courts today.
A note about this information
This information is general and educational, and isn’t a substitute for advice from a qualified medical professional. Anyone facing a mesothelioma diagnosis should discuss their specific situation with their care team.
We’re here to help.
Connect with Mesothelioma Options for help and support.
Help, hope and support.
You don’t have to navigate this alone. Contact Mesothelioma Options.